Energy News
ENERGY TECH
Fusion's future in the US could come down to dollars and cents
Steady-state and pulsed represent two different design approaches to fusion reactors. A steady-state fusion reactor would operate like a traditional power plant, running almost full-time. A pulsed fusion reactor, on the other hand, would be required to shut down for a short time and then restart every hour or every few hours. (stock image only)
Fusion's future in the US could come down to dollars and cents
by Staff Writers
Princeton NJ (SPX) Mar 17, 2023

Fusion energy is often hailed as a limitless source of clean energy, but new research from Princeton University suggests that may only be true if the price is right.

In a study led by fusion expert Egemen Kolemen, associate professor of mechanical and aerospace engineering and the Andlinger Center for Energy and the Environment, and energy systems expert Jesse Jenkins, assistant professor of mechanical and aerospace engineering and the Andlinger Center for Energy and the Environment, Princeton researchers modeled the cost targets that a fusion reactor might have to meet to gain traction in a future U.S. energy grid.

The findings, published in Joule on Mar. 16, illustrated that the engineering challenges of fusion energy are only part of the problem - the other part lies in economics.

"People will not pay an unlimited amount of money for fusion energy if they could spend that money to generate clean energy more cost-effectively," said Jacob Schwartz, a former postdoc with Kolemen and Jenkins who led the modeling for the study and currently works as a research physicist at the Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory. "Above a certain cost, even if we can engineer them, not many developers will want to build them."

The model results demonstrated that the niche for fusion in the U.S. depends not only on the price of building a reactor but hinges greatly on the energy mix of the future grid and the cost of competing technologies like nuclear fission.

If the market for fusion is favorable, then even with capital costs as high as around $7000 per kilowatt, fusion could still reach 100 GW capacity - about the current capacity of U.S. nuclear power plants, which supply about a fifth of today's electricity needs. But supposing alternative technologies like nuclear fission, hydrogen, carbon capture and storage, or long-duration battery storage successfully take root, capital costs might have to be less than half that price for fusion to reach the same 100 GW capacity.

"Fusion developers need to keep an eye on the competition," Jenkins explained. "If successfully commercialized, fusion power plants are likely to look a lot like classic nuclear fission plants from the perspective of electricity markets and grids. Both resources are complex technologies with tight engineering margins for safety reasons, which translates to high upfront investment costs. If the variable costs of fusion power plants end up low, fusion plants will likely compete head-to-head with new fission power plants."

Fusion's place in a renewables-heavy grid
Kolemen explained that the researchers' approach helped establish concrete goals for prospective fusion developers to use as benchmarks when considering plans for reactors.

"Many fusion startups are popping up, all with different reactor designs, saying they can build a reactor with this or that amount of money. But it's almost impossible to assign dollar amounts to individual reactor components," Kolemen said. "So instead, we considered a future grid model with more renewables like wind and solar and worked backward to understand the cost targets that fusion reactors might have to meet to have a place in that future grid mix."

By determining the cost targets for fusion reactors in a grid likely to be dominated by renewable electricity sources like solar and wind, the researchers also gained insight that could inform the design of future fusion reactors.

For example, Schwartz said fusion energy has traditionally been seen as a 'baseload' energy source that would operate almost continuously. With widespread solar adoption and subsequently cheap midday electricity prices, however, the research suggests it would be valuable to add functionality to a fusion reactor to enable it to toggle on and off more frequently or to consider ways to store the energy from the reactor and sell it when it is most needed. The researchers said integrating storage into the design of a fusion reactor could increase its value by up to $1000 per kilowatt.

"Capturing more economic value by coupling thermal storage and operating flexibly means the first fusion power plants can compete with higher initial costs," said Jenkins. "That higher 'go-to-market' price point could be key to kickstart the fusion industry and help lower costs over time through experience and incremental innovation."

The model also suggested that the most promising locations for fusion energy in the U.S. would be in the northeastern region, where local solar and wind opportunities are more limited than in other areas.

"The northeast doesn't have the same potential for geothermal or hydropower energy as the western U.S. does, so it's the place where something besides solar and wind will be most needed," said Wilson Ricks, a study co-author and graduate student in mechanical and aerospace engineering.

Exploring the pulsed vs. steady-state debate
In addition to considering fusion energy in the context of a future energy grid, the model also returned initial results that the researchers said could help settle an important question in the fusion research community between the viability of steady-state versus pulsed fusion reactors.

Steady-state and pulsed represent two different design approaches to fusion reactors. A steady-state fusion reactor would operate like a traditional power plant, running almost full-time. A pulsed fusion reactor, on the other hand, would be required to shut down for a short time and then restart every hour or every few hours.

While some scientists have questioned whether the operating requirements for pulsed reactors would make them difficult to integrate with the rest of the energy grid, the model results suggested no significant difference between the two designs regarding their effects on the large-scale grid.

"There's been somewhat of a design battle between the two technologies, so it was interesting that our initial findings suggest there wasn't much of a difference in how they would operate with the rest of the grid," Kolemen said. "From the viewpoint of the model, the best design is simply the cheapest one."

The researchers are following up their findings with additional research on the different costs and opportunities for steady-state and pulsed reactors, as well as how maintenance and upkeep costs could also play a role in the penetration of fusion energy in the U.S. market.

"This research doesn't claim to know when fusion will come online. Fusion reactors may still be decades away from having a large impact on the energy grid. What this research gives us is a clear target for fusion researchers and startups to aim for when they do come online," Kolemen said. "The end goal of fusion research is to provide some value to the U.S. and the grid. Now, we actually have some numbers to guide us."

Research Report:The value of fusion energy to a decarbonized United States electric grid

Related Links
Andlinger Center for Energy and the Environment
Powering The World in the 21st Century at Energy-Daily.com

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters
Tweet

RELATED CONTENT
The following news reports may link to other Space Media Network websites.
ENERGY TECH
DOE announces new funding for public-private partnerships to advance fusion energy
Oak Ridge TN (SPX) Jan 18, 2023
The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) has announced $2.3 million in funding for 10 projects that will pair private industry with DOE's National Laboratories to overcome challenges in fusion energy development, an area of research that captivated global attention in December when the Department announced that a team at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory had achieved fusion ignition. Ignition, in which more energy was derived from fusion than was put into it, had never been accomplished before in ... read more

ENERGY TECH
EU bids to clean up product 'greenwashing' mess

Record renewables boost in 2022, not enough to slow warming: agency

Germany hits emissions-reduction target in 2022

Corporate transparency on emissions falls short: report

ENERGY TECH
Stalactites and stalagmites in the battery

Fusion's future in the US could come down to dollars and cents

Crab shells could help power the next generation of rechargeable batteries

Development of a self-resonant smart energy harvester

ENERGY TECH
UK offshore staff 'want public ownership of energy firms'

Machine learning could help kites and gliders to harvest wind energy

Polish MPs vote to make building wind turbines easier

New research shows porpoises not harmed by offshore windfarms

ENERGY TECH
Modelling superfast processes in organic solar cell material

Perovskite solar cells from the slot die coater - a step towards industrial production

Solar industry feeling the heat over disposal of 80 million panels

Scientists create novel bandgap-tunable 2D nanosheets made from perovskite oxynitrides

ENERGY TECH
Russian uranium delivery to France 'scandalous': Greenpeace

UN nuclear chief says Ukraine plant situation 'remains perilous'

Rolls-Royce wins UK funds for 'Moon' nuclear reactors

GE Hitachi BWRX-300 Small Modular Reactor achieves pre-licensing milestone in Canada

ENERGY TECH
Turning vegetable oil industry waste into power

European consortium sets CO2 to fuel efficiency record using earth-abundant materials

Cow manure fuels French tractors

How a record-breaking copper catalyst converts CO2 into liquid fuels

ENERGY TECH
Green hydrogen: How photoelectrochemical water splitting may become competitive

Kuwait desert oil spill sparks 'state of emergency': company

North Sea oil and gas staff vote to strike: union

China holds 'upper hand' in Russian gas exports

ENERGY TECH
Dreaming the impossible dream: the 1.5C climate target

U.N. secretary-general warns world is at a global warming crossroads

Governments to vet crucial UN climate science report

Governments vet crucial UN climate science report

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2024 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Statement Our advertisers use various cookies and the like to deliver the best ad banner available at one time. All network advertising suppliers have GDPR policies (Legitimate Interest) that conform with EU regulations for data collection. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.