Energy News
ENERGY NEWS
Court rules S. Korea climate goals 'unconstitutional'
Reuters Events SMR and Advanced Reactor 2025
Court rules S. Korea climate goals 'unconstitutional'
by AFP Staff Writers
Seoul (AFP) Aug 29, 2024

South Korea's Constitutional Court ruled Thursday that much of the country's climate goals were unconstitutional, handing a landmark victory to young environmental activists, who wept for joy on the court steps.

The first such case in Asia, brought by children and teenagers who named an embryo as a lead plaintiff, claimed that South Korea's legally binding climate commitments were insufficient and unmet, violating their constitutionally guaranteed human rights.

"Just now, the Constitutional Court ruled that it is unconstitutional that there is no government goal to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from 2031 to 2050," said Yoon Hyeon-jeong, one of the young activists involved.

"It was ruled that our right to live a safe life from the climate crisis should be guaranteed," she added, barely managing to finish her sentence as she choked up with tears.

The court ruled that the government's limited climate targets violate the constitution as they do "not sufficiently protect the basic rights of the people," the legal representatives of the plaintiffs said after the hearing.

The case -- known as "Woodpecker et al. v. South Korea" after the in-utero nickname of an embryo, now toddler, involved -- included four petitions by children.

In 2021, South Korea made a legally binding commitment to reduce carbon emissions by 290 million tons by 2030 -- and to achieve net-zero carbon emissions by 2050.

To meet this goal, the country needs to reduce emissions by 5.4 percent every year from 2023 -- a target they have so far failed to meet.

As a result of the ruling, Seoul will now have to revise its climate goals, said Youn Se-jong, a lawyer for the plaintiffs

"The National Assembly and the government of the Republic of Korea will have to revise regulations related to the Framework Act on Carbon Neutrality and present greenhouse gas reduction goals considering the rights of future generations," Youn said.

"With today's ruling, we have confirmed that climate change is a matter of our fundamental rights and that everyone has the right to be safe from it," he said.

"Ordinary people like us have come this far. We have led the constitutional petition to protect our rights without relying on authority and power. It took us five years," said youth climate activist Kim Seo-gyeong, 21.

Kim was part of the group that filed the first of the cases in 2020, and said the ruling was a validation for young people who found themselves "living in the climate crisis."

- 'Wish came true' -

Seoul's Ministry of Environment said in a statement that it respected the court's decision.

The ministry said it plans "to faithfully implement follow-up measures".

The plaintiffs had argued that unless Seoul moved more quickly on climate goals, future generations would not only have to live in a degraded environment, but also have to bear the burden of undertaking massive greenhouse gas reductions.

This, the case claims, would mean that the state has violated its duty to protect their fundamental rights.

Similar climate cases globally have found success.

A youth-led effort recently succeeded in the US state of Montana, while another is being heard at the European Higher Court.

In Germany, in 2021 climate targets were ruled insufficient and unconstitutional, and lawyer Lee Chi-sun said the two cases were very similar.

"Just as Germany has further strengthened its reduction targets for 2040 and revised the goal for 2045 after their ruling, we expect Seoul's 2030 reduction targets will be strengthened" and expanded, he said.

Other cases have not fared so well globally -- a child-led suit in California over alleged government failures to curb pollution was thrown out in May.

The Thursday ruling is the first in Asia to question a country's national greenhouse gas reduction targets "and the court's ruling can set an important precedent for other courts in Asia to rule on similar cases," said Lin Yan-Ting, a climate activist who is a plaintiff for a similar case in Taiwan, filed in January.

Outside the Seoul court 12-year-old plaintiff, Han Jeah -- who started the case aged 10 -- said the verdict was "like a wish came true."

"We have the right to live safely and happily even in the climate crisis. This right should be protected under any circumstances and cannot be infringed upon by anyone," Han Jeah said.

"So I wanted to show people through this lawsuit how much we (young people) know and how deeply we worry about climate change."

Related Links

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters
Tweet

RELATED CONTENT
The following news reports may link to other Space Media Network websites.
ENERGY NEWS
Big polluters urged to pay as key Pacific summit opens in Tonga
Nuku'Alofa, Tonga (AFP) Aug 26, 2024
Emissions-belching nations were challenged to stump up for climate-related damage as a key Pacific islands summit opened on Monday, with low-lying Tuvalu declaring: "If you pollute, you should pay." The Pacific Islands Forum got underway in Tonga's capital Nuku'alofa, with leaders hoping to draw global attention to the region's worsening climate plight. "We really need to ensure that we continue to push for action from countries that are the most polluting," Tuvalu Climate Minister Maina Talia ... read more

ENERGY NEWS
Treasury Department, IRS, propose expansion of clean energy tax credits

Court rules S. Korea climate goals 'unconstitutional'

Russia's largest strike in weeks hits Ukraine's power grid

Big polluters urged to pay as key Pacific summit opens in Tonga

ENERGY NEWS
Researchers discover a surprising way to jump-start battery performance

Innovative smart windows cool buildings and generate electricity without external power

Study of disordered rock salts leads to battery breakthrough

Quenching the intense heat of a fusion plasma may require a well-placed liquid metal evaporator

ENERGY NEWS
Researchers develop method for chemically recyclable wind turbine blades

India's green energy wind drive hits desert herders hard

MIT engineers' new theory could improve the design and operation of wind farms

Engineers Develop Cost-Effective Seafloor Testing Device for Offshore Wind Farms

ENERGY NEWS
Custom innovations for fault detection in renewable power grids

AI-powered process unveils chemical keys for solar energy advancements

China's solar sector blazes trail in commitment to renewables

Quarter of China's energy now comes from non-carbon sources: white paper

ENERGY NEWS
Framatome Gains U.S. Approval to Transport Higher Enriched Nuclear Fuel

EDF, Westinghouse protest S.Korean rival's Czech nuclear deal

UN nuclear head to visit Russian plant near fighting

Putin 'very rational', says ex-Iraq weapons inspector Blix

ENERGY NEWS
Engineered microbes efficiently convert CO2 into key pharmaceutical precursors

UK power firm to pay fine over inaccurate data on wood

Turning bacteria into bioplastic factories

UCF Researcher Develops Nature-Inspired Technology to Convert CO2 into Useful Fuels and Chemicals

ENERGY NEWS
Yemen's Huthis blew up stranded oil tanker: video

UK govt says will not fight Rosebank oil field legal challenge

Pentagon: Houthi-attacked tanker is leaking oil

Iraq fire tears through fuel tankers, kills one driver

ENERGY NEWS
Swiss govt denounces landmark European court climate ruling

COP29 finance draft reveals divided positions

EU faces legal challenge over 'grossly inadequate' climate goals

Guidelines proposed for evaluating solar geoengineering research

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2024 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Statement Our advertisers use various cookies and the like to deliver the best ad banner available at one time. All network advertising suppliers have GDPR policies (Legitimate Interest) that conform with EU regulations for data collection. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.