Energy News  
Canada's Afghanistan mission tally 10.5 billion dollars so far

by Staff Writers
Ottawa (AFP) Oct 9, 2008
Routing out insurgents from Afghanistan and rebuilding the war-torn nation has so far cost Canada up to an estimated 10.5 billion dollars (Canadian), an official said Thursday.

And the amount is expected to nearly double to 18.1 billion dollars (15.8 billion US), or about 1,500 dollars (1,309 US) per Canadian household, by the mission's end in 2011, parliamentary budget officer Kevin Page said in a report.

"This is the first comprehensive costing of Canada's Afghanistan mission covering military operations, development aid and reconstruction costs, and the long-term costs of taking care of Canada's veterans," he told reporters.

Military operations accounted for much of the costs, at up to 7.42 billion dollars (6.47 billion US), followed by veterans' benefits at 2.08 billion dollars (1.81 billion US), and 0.97 billion dollars (0.85 billion US) in aid for Afghanistan.

The study does not include the cost of diplomatic efforts, nor does it presume to "put a monetary value on the heroic efforts of brave Canadian soldiers who have given up their life in service to Canada," said the report.

Accelerated procurement of military equipment and danger pay for soldiers was also excluded from the final amount "due to lack of reliable data," it said.

"This suggests that the estimates provided may understate the costs of Canada's mission in Afghanistan," Page said in his report.

At a press conference, he underscored his use of incremental costs in the study, not full costs. "If we were to provide an estimate on a full cost basis, it would be a much larger number," he said.

Incremental costs are costs that would not have been incurred except for the operation, such as equipment maintenance due to an increased operational tempo in war, reservists' pay, and more death and disability benefits for soldiers and their families.

Full costs are those incurred by the Department of National Defence regardless of war or peace, such as soldiers' regular salaries.

To date, the Canadian government has cited a lower cost estimate for the war in Afghanistan of eight billion dollars (seven billion US).

Prime Minister Stephen Harper Thursday took issue with the parliamentary budget officer's inclusion of certain costs in his report.

"Clearly, it's an expensive mission," said Harper. "We're not hiding the fact that these things are expensive."

But, "the parliamentary budget officer has included some very long-term costs that don't relate in our judgment to the day to day of the mission," he said.

All of the monies for the mission were set aside in past budgets, he added.

Page meanwhile urged federal departments to agree on a common, transparent costing methodology, and the next parliament to adopt an accrual-based appropriation system from the current cash-based system.

"When compared with international experience, Canada appears to lag behind the best practices of other jurisdictions in terms of the quality and frequency of war cost reporting to their respective legislatures," he commented.

"Although Canada is in the seventh year of the mission, parliament has not (until now) been provided with estimates by successive governments on the fiscal costs incurred by all relevant departments," Page said in his report.

Liberal leader Stephane Dion responded to the report by accusing Harper of "false transparency."

"We don't know year in and year out what were the problems, how much we've gone over the budgetary framework, and I think Canadians are entitled to that information, and they'll get it with me," he said, amid an election campaign.

Canada maintains 2,500 soldiers in Afghanistan's southern Kandahar province as part of the NATO-led International Security Assistance Force (ISAF).

Since they first deployed in 2002, 97 Canadian troops have died in roadside blasts and in melees with Taliban insurgents. Two Canadian aid workers and a senior diplomat have also been killed.

In March, the House of Commons approved prolonging Canada's presence in Afghanistan to 2011, and at the start of the election campaign last month Harper ruled out any extension beyond that date.

Community
Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Share This Article With Planet Earth
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook



Related Links
News From Across The Stans



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


NATO battles to agree new steps against Afghan drug trade
Budapest (AFP) Oct 9, 2008
NATO nations struggled Thursday to agree new steps to combat opium production in Afghanistan by hunting down drug lords and laboratories in an effort to halt the flow of funds to Taliban insurgents.







  • Ethiopia signs deal for largest wind farm in Africa
  • Analysis: Caspian states ponder new group
  • Outside View: Oil price Iran attack factor
  • Outside View: The oil dimension of war

  • Lithuania to vote on delaying EU-agreed nuclear shutdown
  • Hungary inaugurates first stage of nuclear waste disposal facility
  • German power giant to run Bulgarian nuclear plant: ministry
  • Rice in India, but no signature for nuclear pact

  • Measuring The Weight Of Ancient Air
  • On Rocky Mountain Beetle Kill Could Impact Regional Air Quality
  • An Explanation For Night-Shining Clouds At The Edge Of Space
  • Seabird Ammonia Emissions Contribute To Atmospheric Acidity

  • Rainforest dwellers caught between business, green groups
  • Consensus takes form on forests and climate change
  • Wetlands Restoration Not A Panacea For Louisiana Coast
  • Campaign Launched To Re-Forest America

  • China more than triples figure for children hospitalised over milk
  • Milk safety checks tightened in China, but inspectors scarce
  • China reluctant to reveal tainted milk figures
  • China sets limits for melamine in milk

  • France's Renault, EDF plug into electric car market
  • France targets more clean cars
  • Pepco Energy Services Supplies Natural Gas For WMATA's Energy-Efficient Buses
  • Quantum Ships New Generation Hybrid Electric Vehicles To US Army

  • Researchers Scientists Perform High Altitude Experiments
  • Airbus expecting 'large' China order by early 2009: CEO
  • Airbus globalises production with China plant
  • Safer Skies For The Flying Public



  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement