Berlin (UPI) Apr 12, 2011
Turkey's ambition to become an energy hub has been one of the major hurdles for new Europe-bound natural gas pipelines, an energy expert said Tuesday.
"Turkey doesn't want to be just an energy transit country," German gas expert Roland Goetz Tuesday told the foreign press corps in Berlin. "Ankara wants to dictate pipeline plans, and it wants to make a profit itself."
This desire, Goetz added, has led to problems for two very different natural gas pipeline projects -- Nabucco and South Stream.
Backed by the European Commission, Nabucco would bring Central Asian and Middle Eastern gas to Europe in a bid to diversify Europe's energy import structure away from Russia. South Stream was jump-started by the Kremlin to bypass traditional transit countries Ukraine and Belarus and transport Russian gas unilaterally to Europe.
What unites the pipelines is that they both run through Turkish territory.
Russia has been trying to convince Turkey to have South Stream cross its territorial waters in the Black Sea. So far, Ankara has refused, saying it needed more documentation on economics, routes and environmental impact. Gazprom said it aims to make a decision on the route of the pipeline by the middle of 2011.
Nabucco has tried to secure gas deliveries from Turkey's neighbor Azerbaijan and from Turkmenistan. A clear commitment from either one of these nations is needed to realize Nabucco, experts say.
It would be in Turkey's interest that at least South Stream isn't realized, as it's going to be filled with Russian gas and there's little profit to be made for Turkey, Goetz said.
Not so with Nabucco: Turkey could easily boost its already existent domestic pipeline network, buy up Azeri and Turkmen gas, and sell that to a shorter Nabucco pipeline that begins at Turkey's Western border.
"Compared to an expensive pipeline that starts in Azerbaijan, this might even be a more economical solution," Goetz said.
Nabucco is to transport up to 31 billion cubic meters of Caspian and Middle Eastern gas per year to Europe. Its consortium includes Germany's RWE as well as companies from Austria, Hungary, Bulgaria and Turkey.
South Stream would have a capacity of 63 billion cubic meters and is planned to run under the Black Sea. The consortium is backed by Gazprom and Italy's Eni, which both own 50 percent in the consortium.
The pipeline recently received a major boost when Wintershall, the oil and gas arm of German chemicals giant BASF, said it would join the consortium, acquiring a 15 percent stake. France's EDF had announced last year that it would take 10 percent. The shares are expected to come from Eni's stake.
Critics have accused Russia of launching South Stream to torpedo Nabucco.
The South Stream consortium members deny this, arguing their pipeline makes economic sense.
Experts have in the past questioned whether there is room for both projects as they vie for similar sources and customers, with analysts speaking of a "pipeline war."
A possible demise of nuclear power in Japan and at least parts of Europe could boost the gas demand significantly and increase chances for both Nabucco and South Stream to co-exist, analysts have said.
Share This Article With Planet Earth
Powering The World in the 21st Century at Energy-Daily.com
Transocean claims record sea depth for oil drilling
Zurich (AFP) April 12, 2011
Offshore oil drilling group Transocean claimed Tuesday that it had a set a world record for deep water drilling at an ocean depth of 3,107 metres (10,194 feet) off the coast of India. The depth was achieved by the ultra-deepwater drillship Dhirubhai Deepwater KG2, surpassing the previous record of 10,011 feet, also set by Transocean in 2003 in the Gulf of Mexico, the group said in a statemen ... read more
Japan's post-disaster economy faces electric shock|
Japan sets power-saving targets
Mekong Countries To Convene Additional Meeting On Xayaburi Project
Facebook makes data centers greener and cheaper
OPEC raises 2011 world oil demand growth forecast
Turkish gas ambitions derail EU pipelines
Shale gas as dirty as oil, coal for warming: study
Outside View: Gas prices and consumers
Manitoba wind farm comes online
Alstom Announces Commercial Operation Of First North American Wind Farms
Vestas unveils new offshore turbine
US hopes to resolve China wind turbine rift
S.Africa to invest $3.7 bln in green energy: minister
Sacramento Welcomes 12,600 Solar Panels
Legends Business Group Adds Solar Charger Controllers
DOE Finalizes Large Loan Guarantee For BrightSource Energy
Japan utility suspends nuclear expansion after crisis
Researchers Improve Path To Producing Uranium Compounds For Advanced Nuclear Fuels
Switzerland says considering nuclear shutdown
Britain's plans for nuclear waste on hold
Nanoparticles Increase Biofuel
Economics, Physics Are Roadblocks For Mass-Scale Algae Biodiesel Production
Advance Toward Making Biodegradable Plastics From Waste Chicken Features
Short Rotation Energy Crops Could Help Meet UK's Renewable Energy Targets
What Future for Chang'e-2
China setting up new rocket production base
China's Tiangong-1 To Be Launched By Modified Long March II-F Rocket
China Expects To Launch Fifth Lunar Probe Chang'e-5 In 2017
Climate Change Poses Major Risks For Unprepared Cities
Rich, poor nations feud at UN climate talks
Number Of Days Of Rain In Iberian Peninsula Has Increased Since 1903
Climate Beliefs Shift With Weather
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement|