Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
  Energy News  

Subscribe free to our newsletters via your

The Greening Of Patent Litigation

Enercon wind energy turbine.
by Staff Writers
Washington DC (SPX) Apr 17, 2008
The Cleantech Group at Heslin Rothenberg Farley and Mesiti P.C. continues to monitor Intellectual Property trends in the Cleantech arena. In addition to its signature Clean Energy Patent Growth Index, the Group has analyzed litigation trends in the clean energy area and has found that litigation has proliferated over the last several years.

Issued patents are one indicator of innovation in clean energy technology, and recent litigation in this sector indicates the technology is becoming financially viable to justify patent enforcement. Several cases filed in the federal courts reveals the increasing importance of clean energy patents.

A significant case involving one of the largest wind turbine manufacturers in the world, Enercon, emerged ten years ago. In Enercon v. ITC, the ITC excluded Enercon's variable speed wind turbines from entering the US after Kenetech Windpower filed a complaint alleging that Enercon's wind turbines infringed its patents for controlling AC power output.

The Federal Circuit affirmed the ITC's decision, prohibiting Enercon from importing its wind turbines into the US until 2010. In Southwest Windpower v. Aeromax, Southwest, a manufacturer of small wind turbines, claimed that Aeromax's wind turbines infringed its patent.

An Arizona court issued an injunction prohibiting sales of Aeromax's wind turbine. In Gamesa Eolica, v. General Electric, Gamesa claimed that GE infringed its patent directed to a speed wind turbine that converts variable frequency AC to fixed frequency AC and maneuvers turbine speed to increase efficiency. A Wisconsin court found no infringement in favor of GE.

In Paice v. Toyota, Paice claimed that Toyota's hybrid vehicles included a drive train similar to one covered by its patents. A Texas court held that Toyota infringed Paice's patent, but denied an injunction and allowed Toyota to continue selling its hybrid cars for a royalty payment of $25 for each car sold during the life of the patent. The case was affirmed on appeal.

In Ovonic v. Matsushita, in Michigan, Ovonic claimed Matsushita's hybrid electric vehicles infringed its patents covering nickel metal hydride batteries. The parties ultimately entered into a settlement agreement that included a cross-license and a combined license fee of $30 million.

In Maxwell Technologies v. NessCap, a California case, Maxwell, a manufacturer of ultracapacitors for hybrid cars and renewable energy sources, filed a complaint against Nesscap, a Korean competitor, to enforce its patents related to electric double layer capacitors.

The court entered a preliminary injunction enjoining NessCap from selling its prismatic ultracapacitor products. Then, in January 2007, Nesscap filed its own suit against Maxwell, alleging that Maxwell's ultracapacitors infringe a NessCap patent. Both cases remain pending.

Other pending cases include, ReliOn, Inc. v. Hydra Fuel Cell, in which ReliOn claims Hydra infringed its patent directed to fuel cell power systems, and Quantum Catalytics v. Ze-gen, in which Quantum alleges its waste service competitors infringe numerous patents directed to gasification methods for creating compounds from waste, such as hydrogen and carbon monoxide, that can be used to generate electricity.

The existence of clean energy patent cases throughout the country is evidence of the substantial value of these patents and, if the market for clean energy continues to grow, the number of patent cases is likely to increase as more patents are granted.

Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Related Links
Clean Energy Patent Growth Index
Powering The World in the 21st Century at

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

Analysis: Reps. want old FutureGen back

The Department of Energy's new plans for the FutureGen project -- a 5-year-old initiative to develop clean-coal technology -- look fishy, policymakers said Tuesday.

  • Analysis: Iraq oil law a deal -- spokesman
  • Historic Alliance Calls For A National Task Force On Carbon Capture And Storage
  • Analysis: Reps. want old FutureGen back
  • The Greening Of Patent Litigation

  • Nuclear plant chiefs fire officers over radioactive leak
  • Spain's Endesa accused of downplaying nuclear incident
  • Nuclear power has important role in reducing CO2: Brussels
  • Russia, Mongolia sign uranium accord: reports

  • Viruses Keep Us Breathing
  • Carnegie Mellon Researchers To Curb CO2 Emissions
  • Scientists Identify Origin Of Hiss In Upper Atmosphere
  • NASA Co-Sponsors Ocean Voyage To Probe Climate-Relevant Gases

  • Forests' Long-Term Potential For Carbon Offsetting
  • Indonesian police arrest three officers over illegal logging
  • The Tree Corporation Of Australia
  • Carbon credits could help save Amazon, blunt warming: study

  • World must reform agriculture now or face dire crisis: report
  • France pushes EU to support farming as food prices soar
  • Philippines calls for Asia food meet as China rebuffs bid to buy wheat
  • Black Gold Agriculture May Revolutionize Farming, Curb Global Warming

  • A Whole New Breed Of Hybrid: The High-Performance Fisker Karma
  • NYC Metro Region's Commitment to Alternative-Fueled Garbage Trucks Showcased
  • How Sweet It Is: Revolutionary Process Points To Sugar-Fueled Cars
  • New York nixes traffic congestion charge

  • Oil spike, cost of planes led to Oasis collapse: founders
  • Airbus boss says aviation unfairly targeted over climate change
  • World grapples with aviation's climate change footprint
  • Europe's EADS finds sweet home in Alabama despite uproar

  • Nuclear Power In Space - Part 2
  • Outside View: Nuclear future in space
  • Nuclear Power In Space

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement