Washington (AFP) Feb 17, 2011
BP's oil well in the Gulf of Mexico might never have blown last year if the company's engineers had been consulted about a key test that pointed to a defective cement job, investigators reported Thursday.
Those and other details were disclosed in a report wrapping up an investigation by a presidential commission that blamed the April 20, 2010 disaster on management failures by BP, Halliburton and Transocean.
A massive explosion on the BP-leased Deepwater Horizon rig killed 11 workers, sank the rig and sent millions of barrels of oil flowing into the Gulf over a three month period, wreaking havoc on the region's environment and economy.
The report by the commission's lead counsel, Fred Bartlit, zeroed in on the failure of the cement well casing put in by Halliburton and a key negative pressure test just before the blowout that should have warned BP supervisors of a problem.
But investigators found that "well site leaders accepted facially implausible explanations for the negative test results."
Even after the blowout of the Macondo well, a BP official attributed it to "a bladder effect," rather than failed cement, surprising BP's vice president for drilling and completions, who was on the rig during the test.
"If anyone had consulted him or any other shore-based engineer, the blowout might never have happened," Bartlit's report said.
"Every industry expert the investigative team met with dismissed the so-called bladder effect as a fiction that could not have accounted for the pressure readings the men saw on April 20."
The report also said that BP officials had been aware for years of problems with Halliburton's work and the quality of the oil services giant's personnel.
"BP's engineers had been forced to 'work around' the Halliburton engineer assigned to Macondo for years -- they said that he was 'not cutting it' and that he often waited too long to conduct critical tests.
"But they neither reviewed his work at Macondo carefully, nor even checked to see that he conducted testing in a timely manner -- even though they knew that their last minute changes to the cement design test could cause problems and that using nitrogen foamed cement could pose 'significant stability challenges.'"
Nor did they fully review his cement design, the report said.
An internal BP cement specialist was asked to provide support on an ad hoc basis, but he left the country without carefully reviewing the cement design, and never saw information about the cement slurry design or the lab test results until six days after the disaster.
"When he reviewed those materials, several aspects of Halliburton's cement design surprised him," it said.
The Transocean crew also missed several signs that there were hydrocarbons on the night of the blowout.
"At 9:27 pm, less than 15 minutes before the blowout began, they did notice an anomaly in pressure data from the well, and shut down operations to investigate," the report said.
"They noticed several anomalies that should have caused serious concern, but showed no hint of alarm," it said.
The rig's crew activated a blowout preventer seconds before the blowout began. But by then it was too late, the report said.
"Even if the BOP (blowout preventer) had functioned flawlessly, the rig would have exploded and 11 men would have died," it said.
Share This Article With Planet Earth
Powering The World in the 21st Century at Energy-Daily.com
Oil turns higher on Chinese economic surge
Singapore (AFP) Jan 21, 2011
Oil prices turned higher in Asian trade Friday as market sentiment was buoyed by strong Chinese economic growth last year, analysts said. New York's main contract, light sweet crude for March delivery, gained 24 cents to 89.83 dollars per barrel. Brent North Sea crude for March advanced 18 cents to 96.76 dollars. Stellar Chinese economic numbers fuelled the crude price rally, said Ja ... read more
India could boost rural electricity: study|
China and the U.S. sign energy deals
Australia's emissions set to rise
S. Korea may delay carbon trading system: official
Ultra-Clean And Reliable Power Generation Drives Purchase Of Direct Fuelcell Power Plant
China upholds US geologist's conviction
Coal's 'real' cost could top $500 billion
Malaysia drops coal power plant scheme: minister
Eon to build fifth U.K. offshore wind farm
GL Garrad Hassan Launches Onshore Wind Resource Mapping For UK
Construction Begins On Dempsey Ridge Wind Project
India's Suzlon wins $1.28 bn wind power deal
The University Of Maryland College Park Announces 631 KW Solar Project
First Solar builds second plant in Germany
MRWPCA And SolarCity complete Megawatt Solar Installation
Mortenson To Build Largest Concentrated Photovoltaic Solar Power Plant In The World
Water Jet Cuts Access Point In Nuclear Waste Storage Tank To Help Manhattan Project Cleanup
Alstom to relocate nuclear part production: union
Hundreds detained in nuclear shipment protest
EDF repairs reactors amid anomalies
Study: Meeting biofuel goal may be costly
New Lignin Lite Switchgrass Boosts Biofuel Yield By More Than One-Third
Race To The BioFuel Pump
Algae in wastewater seen as energy source
U.S. wary of China space weapons
Slow progress in U.S.-China space efforts
China Builds Theme Park In Spaceport
Tiangong Space Station Plans Progessing
China farmers to get $15 bn subsidies amid drought
Man, Volcanoes And The Sun Have Influenced Europe's Climate Over Recent Centuries
Cross-Border Conservation Vital To Protect Birds In A Climate-Change World
Snows fall in north China, but drought to persist
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement|